Mohenjo daro and harappa radioactive dating

Harappa - Wikipedia

mohenjo daro and harappa radioactive dating

The ruins of Mohenjo-Daro in the Sindh province of Pakistan. Picture of the Day discussions about radioactive decay rates and how external. The Indus Valley Civilisation (IVC), or Harappan Civilisation, was a Bronze Age civilisation The discovery of Harappa, and soon afterwards Mohenjo-daro, was the culmination of work charcoal samples, which were radio-carbon dated at respectively – BCE (sample ) and – BCE (sample ). The radioactive ash adds credibility to the ancient Indian records that Mohenjo- Daro and Harappa are both about km from Jodhpur, one to by a nuclear blast , years ago, dating techniques should make this.

The ruins of Harappa What this candidate has in its favour is that a layer of radioactive ash was indeed found in Rajasthan, India. It covered a three-square mile area, ten miles west of Jodhpur.

The research occurred after a very high rate of birth defects and cancer was discovered in the area.

Mohenjo-daro

Scientists then apparently unearthed an ancient city where they found evidence of an atomic blast dating back thousands of years: The blast was said to have destroyed most of the buildings and probably a half-million people.

So far, this story seems to have all the necessary credentials. Archaeologist Francis Taylor stated that etchings in some nearby temples he translated, suggested that they prayed to be spared from the great light that was coming to lay ruin to the city.

The radioactive ash adds credibility to the ancient Indian records that describe atomic warfare. People were just lying, unburied, in the streets of the city; there seemed no-one available to bury them afterwards. What could cause such a thing? Why did the bodies not decay or get eaten by wild animals? Furthermore, there is no apparent cause of a physically violent death. These appear to be fragments of clay vessels that melted together in extreme heat.

Another curious sign of an ancient nuclear war in India is a giant crater near Mumbai formerly Bombay. The nearly circular 2,metre-diameter Lonar crater, located kilometres northeast of Mumbai and dated at less than 50, years old, could be related to nuclear warfare of antiquity.

Mohenjo Daro and Harappa

No trace of any meteoric material, etc. Indications of great shock from a pressure exceedingatmospheres and intense, abrupt heat indicated by basalt glass spherules can be ascertained from the site. The Harappan Civilization by Tarini J.

  • Le site d’Irna
  • Defusing India's Ancient Atomic Blasts

Carr It wasn't till that excavations began in earnest at Harappa. John Marshall, then the director of the Archaeological Survey of India, started a new excavation at Harappa. Along with finds from another archaeologist, who was excavating at Mohenjo Daro, Marshall believed that what they had found gave evidence of a new civilization that was older than any they had known.

The city had many drinking water wells, and a highly sophisticated system of waste removal. All Harappan houses were equipped with latrines, bathing houses, and sewage drains which emptied into larger mains and eventually deposited the fertile sludge on surrounding agricultural fields. Seals are one of the most commonly found objects in Harappan cities.

They are decorated with animal motifs such as elephants, water buffalo, tigers, and most commonly unicorns. Some of these seals are inscribed with figures that are prototypes to later Hindu religious figures, some of which are seen today.

This was at least the case insee the first link given at the bottom of the page. His writings are about how to win the lottery by the power of thought, man has lived side by side with dinosaurs, the phenomenon of poltergeists, the art of divination, the antediluvian civilizations, etc etc Since this reference is so often cited, one would expect solid arguments. But the passage about Mohenjo Daro is surprisingly short page There are some other finds that also surprise the investigator.

In this regard, one is reminded of the find of a human skeleton in India, which radioactivity was 50 times higher than normal! The deposits that were found in the skeleton could only have had such a high radioactivity if this person, who died 4, years ago, had eaten food, which contained radioactivity hundred of times higher than normal. We learn that one and only one radioactive skeleton has been discovered somewhere in India. It is years old, while the alleged nuclear disaster of Mohenjo Daro is years old.

mohenjo daro and harappa radioactive dating

A dating can sometimes lack precision. Luckily, mention is made of the article Problems of Space Biology. Lebedinsky The exact title is Problems of radiation safety in cosmic flights by A.

Mohenjo Daro 101 - National Geographic

Problems of Space Biology also exists, but it is an incomplete English translation for the Nasa from This is a Russian scientific article that addresses the possible risks to humans in a space environment. Sadly for the legend, there is nothing remotely like this story in any archaeological publications.

Archaeological information about the excavations of Mohenjo-Daro, Harappa, and other Indus Valley sites is widely available online and in print, and there is simply no such thing as radioactive skeletons or skeletons in large numbers or holding hands or sprawled in any way that the archaeologists saw reason to print. The next easiest thing to check would be those quotes from the Mahabharata.

At a minimum I wanted to see the context of those passages. I went to an online searchable Mahabharata to look for these quotes, and Couldn't find anything even vaguely like them. Could it be possible that whoever originated this tale made up its primary source? Let's set that possibility aside for a moment, and see what we can verify about the rest of the story.

How about the residual radioactivity west of Jodhpur. There is one little fact that casts some pretty grave doubt on the claim that Jodhpur is in a zone with dangerously high radiation.

mohenjo daro and harappa radioactive dating

The story says we detect that radiation today, and suffer high birth defects and cancer, left over from this nuclear waryears ago. Radioactivity goes down over time, so if it's that lethal today, it would have been even more lethal years ago when the city of Jodhpur was founded.

It would seem a poor choice to locate a new city. However, Jodhpur was founded, and has flourished ever since. Furthermore, the vast majority of radioactive isotopes produced in a nuclear blast have extremely short half lives measured in seconds, hours, or days, and are reduced to safe levels very quickly. Those that pose the greatest threat to human health are Cesium and Strontium, which have half lives of 30 and 28 years, and so even these would have been reduced to well below the natural background levels thousands of years ago.

Indus Valley Civilisation

Other long-lived isotopes are produced by nuclear explosions, but at much lower amounts. Note that despite the atomic destructions of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, no harmful radiation persists today in either city. Put together all the radiation data, and we know for a fact, with no doubt, that any claims of modern radiation in India proving a prehistoric nuclear war are false. So we have good reason to regard the entire story with great skepticism.

For example, the idea of an ancient city with half a million people, west of Jodhpur. There are no ancient cities anywhere in the region west of Jodhpur, it's the Thar desert; and half a million people would be immense, and pretty hard for archaeology to miss. This part of the story has to be either dead wrong, or made up.

But that's not the only part of the geography that doesn't make sense. If this was a nuclear war, it was practically a nationwide theater. Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa are both about km from Jodhpur, one to the north and one to the west. None of these places are anywhere near each other. So how about this giant unexplained crater near Bombay? Lonar Crater — which is some kilometers southeast of Jodhpur, even farther away — is indeed a real crater.

Rim to rim it measures about 1. It is blasted out of thick layers of volcanic basalt, deposited over the plateau 66 million years ago. If the crater was indeed formed by a nuclear blastyears ago, dating techniques should make this easy to determine. For a long time, the accepted age of Lonar Crater was 52, years; far too old to have been part of this alleged nuclear war. This had been determined by thermoluminescence dating, which tells us when the sample was last molten.